Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jumping coordinates? #132

Open
onekiloparsec opened this issue Aug 26, 2024 · 0 comments
Open

Jumping coordinates? #132

onekiloparsec opened this issue Aug 26, 2024 · 0 comments

Comments

@onekiloparsec
Copy link

onekiloparsec commented Aug 26, 2024

Hey. I am a happy user of your truly awesome library. I am currently trying to display Starlink tracks onto the sky, using the Aladin Lite viewer, which is a lib I know since a long time too.

Hence, I compute the LookAngles exactly as explained in your README, using TLEs obtained from CelesTrack.org (which is based on space-track.org, as far as I can tell). And I transform these LookAngles into equatorial coordinates, and inject them into Aladin Lite.

I noticed that some tracks are just jumping around, with huge shifts (> 10 degrees) of azimuth and/or elevation in just a few seconds. Most of other tracks looks pefectly fine.

I really checked everything (especially, this is true at the LookAngle step, and not due to the transform to Equatorial Coordinates). I also checked the validity of TLEs, and everything looks fine.

I attach below two images. The first one has 2 bad tracks. The second one has 3 good ones. Every green track displayed consists of 300 points spread over the course of 2 hours, at the same date, same location. I also attach associated satellite records (one bad, one good).

Do you have any idea on what could cause this, in some cases (and not others)? Do I make any mistake somewhere? Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks a lot!

Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 17 56 37 Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 18 04 44

exemple bad track:

{
    "error": 0,
    "satnum": "56532",
    "epochyr": 24,
    "epochdays": 236.11336932,
    "ndot": 0.00001791,
    "nddot": 0,
    "bstar": 0.00014762,
    "inclo": 0.7505613915276415,
    "nodeo": 0.3497273301853718,
    "ecco": 0.0002097,
    "argpo": 4.6203176263542325,
    "mo": 1.663920114364306,
    "no": 0.06553335134631144,
    "jdsatepoch": 2460545.61336932,
    "isimp": 0,
    "method": "n",
    "aycof": 0.000799726717117262,
    "con41": 0.6044257802707943,
    "cc1": 6.161371895173546e-10,
    "cc4": 2.442547801321601e-7,
    "cc5": 0.00012441636586399995,
    "d2": 2.1815917766150275e-17,
    "d3": 1.1541922662844e-24,
    "d4": 7.118037144080292e-32,
    "delmo": 0.9991597869763904,
    "eta": 0.00301270827661509,
    "argpdot": 0.00007532645185525302,
    "omgcof": -1.0244224991108602e-8,
    "sinmao": 0.9956671127001432,
    "t": -76154.31850410998,
    "t2cof": 9.242057842760319e-10,
    "t3cof": 2.2575167838762963e-17,
    "t4cof": 9.06553747248183e-25,
    "t5cof": 4.5036205412872555e-32,
    "x1mth2": 0.4651914065764019,
    "x7thm1": 2.7436601539651866,
    "mdot": 0.06556055001984452,
    "nodedot": -0.00006588339179430682,
    "xlcof": 0.0015373957477788829,
    "xmcof": -0.008906539102513301,
    "nodecf": -1.4179129247233027e-13,
    "irez": 0,
    "d2201": 0,
    "d2211": 0,
    "d3210": 0,
    "d3222": 0,
    "d4410": 0,
    "d4422": 0,
    "d5220": 0,
    "d5232": 0,
    "d5421": 0,
    "d5433": 0,
    "dedt": 0,
    "del1": 0,
    "del2": 0,
    "del3": 0,
    "didt": 0,
    "dmdt": 0,
    "dnodt": 0,
    "domdt": 0,
    "e3": 0,
    "ee2": 0,
    "peo": 0,
    "pgho": 0,
    "pho": 0,
    "pinco": 0,
    "plo": 0,
    "se2": 0,
    "se3": 0,
    "sgh2": 0,
    "sgh3": 0,
    "sgh4": 0,
    "sh2": 0,
    "sh3": 0,
    "si2": 0,
    "si3": 0,
    "sl2": 0,
    "sl3": 0,
    "sl4": 0,
    "gsto": 0.22173464941256782,
    "xfact": 0,
    "xgh2": 0,
    "xgh3": 0,
    "xgh4": 0,
    "xh2": 0,
    "xh3": 0,
    "xi2": 0,
    "xi3": 0,
    "xl2": 0,
    "xl3": 0,
    "xl4": 0,
    "xlamo": 0,
    "zmol": 0,
    "zmos": 0,
    "atime": 0,
    "xli": 0,
    "xni": 0,
    "operationmode": "i",
    "init": "n",
    "a": 1.0879566627398578,
    "alta": 0.08818480725203437,
    "altp": 0.08772851822768124
}

exemple good track:

{
    "error": 0,
    "satnum": "60320",
    "epochyr": 24,
    "epochdays": 236.58334491,
    "ndot": -0.0174653,
    "nddot": 0,
    "bstar": -0.01572,
    "inclo": 0.9278170303601855,
    "nodeo": 0.771007923714755,
    "ecco": 0.0000847,
    "argpo": 0.994746916515664,
    "mo": 5.577347977734299,
    "no": 0.06853208585105452,
    "jdsatepoch": 2460546.08334491,
    "isimp": 0,
    "method": "n",
    "aycof": 0.0009383948661895064,
    "con41": 0.07849740940212402,
    "cc1": -5.868640315491601e-7,
    "cc4": 7.164567296981803e-7,
    "cc5": 0.0010835110607258704,
    "d2": 3.324836217470627e-11,
    "d3": -2.8189891967337796e-15,
    "d4": 2.787056513931511e-19,
    "delmo": 1.0046745441948546,
    "eta": 0.002044177906792021,
    "argpdot": 0.00003969364916096661,
    "omgcof": 0,
    "sinmao": -0.6486713220643282,
    "t": -76831.08335338533,
    "t2cof": -8.8029604732374e-7,
    "t3cof": 3.393718095775854e-11,
    "t4cof": -2.173284004865135e-15,
    "t5cof": 1.7258946935898602e-19,
    "x1mth2": 0.6405008635326254,
    "x7thm1": 1.5164939552716223,
    "mdot": 0.068536011073524,
    "nodedot": -0.0000598566595274696,
    "xlcof": 0.0017593372835821698,
    "xmcof": 0,
    "nodecf": 1.2291352871823714e-10,
    "irez": 0,
    "d2201": 0,
    "d2211": 0,
    "d3210": 0,
    "d3222": 0,
    "d4410": 0,
    "d4422": 0,
    "d5220": 0,
    "d5232": 0,
    "d5421": 0,
    "d5433": 0,
    "dedt": 0,
    "del1": 0,
    "del2": 0,
    "del3": 0,
    "didt": 0,
    "dmdt": 0,
    "dnodt": 0,
    "domdt": 0,
    "e3": 0,
    "ee2": 0,
    "peo": 0,
    "pgho": 0,
    "pho": 0,
    "pinco": 0,
    "plo": 0,
    "se2": 0,
    "se3": 0,
    "sgh2": 0,
    "sgh3": 0,
    "sgh4": 0,
    "sh2": 0,
    "sh3": 0,
    "si2": 0,
    "si3": 0,
    "sl2": 0,
    "sl3": 0,
    "sl4": 0,
    "gsto": 3.1827632620897504,
    "xfact": 0,
    "xgh2": 0,
    "xgh3": 0,
    "xgh4": 0,
    "xh2": 0,
    "xh3": 0,
    "xi2": 0,
    "xi3": 0,
    "xl2": 0,
    "xl3": 0,
    "xl4": 0,
    "xlamo": 0,
    "zmol": 0,
    "zmos": 0,
    "atime": 0,
    "xli": 0,
    "xni": 0,
    "operationmode": "i",
    "init": "n",
    "a": 1.0559837005554569,
    "alta": 0.056073142374893914,
    "altp": 0.05589425873601983
}
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants
@onekiloparsec and others