[BUG] Servier-Side Validation is not disabled on hidden by condition field.

[dkd-kaehm]

Caused by
2f4d0d3#diff-70a09ddce344d5780d1e799fa2eb26f7R64

        $formUid = $form->getUid();
        $pageUid = $parentPage->getUid();
        $marker = $field->getMarker();
        
        if (ConfigurationUtility::isReplaceIrreWithElementBrowserActive()) {
            /** @var Page $page */
            foreach ($form->getPages() as $page) {
                /** @var Field $field */
                foreach ($page->getFields() as $field) {
                    if (!empty($arguments[$formUid][$pageUid][$marker][Condition::INDEX_ACTION])) {
                        if ($arguments[$formUid][$pageUid][$marker][Condition::INDEX_ACTION] ===
                            Condition::ACTION_HIDE_STRING) {
                            return;
                        }
                    }
                }
            }

the array keys in each loop are the same

[einpraegsam]

Thx, seems really a bit strange. Nevertheless I did not recognize an issue on my testsystem. Can you pls give me a hint how to reproduce the issue?

[dkd-kaehm]

Hi,
trying to send form with required/mandatory marked field which is hidden by cond.
You should get validation errors from server.

But expected behaviour is, that hidden by cond fields should NOT be validated on server-side.

[nicozerr]

I had the same problem, but only if I was logged in BE.
Not logged in BE, the hidden mandatory field is well-ignored.

[sarahhoppe]

Same here.
Are there any solutions?
I have the problem, whether I'm logged in or not

[rengaw83]

There are some confusing dependencies.

powermail_cond 6 requires powermail 6.1.
When you use powermail_cond > 6 and powermail < 6.1 it will not work.
For older projects with powermail 6 you has to use powermail_cond 5.
Otherwise the server side validation on submit does not work.

[CarstenKoehler]

I had the same behaviour on my website - took me a while to debug and understand

When creating the form, the conditions get attached to the fe_user session Object
My fe_user object is not persistent as it seems, the cookie "fe_typo_user" has a different value in each request. (Seems this is default behaviour of Typo3 to avoid session fixations etc.)

Oddly enough, when tracing that behaviour it all seems fine in the Database - the session values get transferred from one Session(id) to the next Session(id).

Nevertheless all attempts to retrieve the session values via return $feUser->getSessionData('tx_powermail_cond'); in the SessionAwareValidator fail.

I traced it back to TYPO3\CMS\Core\Authentication\AbstractUserAuthentication class - the powermail_cond values always seem to be NULL

As soon as I got a valid FE-Login everything works as it should...

The PHP-Session stays the same, so setting and getting the values via $_SESSION['tx_powermail_cond'] works like a charm.

Any help is appreciated ..

[christophlehmann]

I'm on an older version, but the code looks the same.

With active isReplaceIrreWithElementBrowserActive() server-side validation might not work, because $field needs to have another name in

https://github.com/einpraegsam/powermail_cond/blob/9.0.4/Classes/Domain/Validator/ConditionAwareValidator.php#L47

After the foreach loop, $field is always the last field of the last page (i guess always the submit button) and the parent method is thus always called for the submit field.

This behaviour didn't changed with 2f4d0d3#diff-70a09ddce344d5780d1e799fa2eb26f7R64