ADF diags: AMWG Table Incorrect Values

[justin-richling]

There has been an issue with the AMWG tables that I have just become aware of. Unfortunately, this appears to be a long running mistake that has rendered variables in the tables incorrect for diagnostics I have posted in the GitHub issues. There is no problem with the code in the main branch of the ADF, so if you have used the ADF on your own, this is not a problem. The incorrect values came from a development branch I was using.

However, the values in the plots were not affected by this bug. The suggested plan of action will be to remove the tables for the old cases and to redo the tables for all cases that are still available on glade. For the cases that I won’t be able to reproduce the tables, if you need the values, please look at the plots for the means.

Thank you for attention and please voice any concerns you may have.

[justin-richling]

As a quick check for b.e23_alpha14a.BLT1850.ne30_t232.032 vs f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT.001, here are the corrected tables (left) vs tables with bug (right).

[justin-richling]

Running list of ADF cases updated:

• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.opt.002_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006

---

• b.e23_alpha14a.BLT1850.ne30_t232.032_1_16_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006
• b.e23_alpha14a.BLT1850.ne30_t232.032_1_16_vs_Obs
• b.e23_alpha14a.BLT1850.ne30_t232.032_1_16_vs_b.cesm3_cam058_mom_e.B1850WscMOM.ne30_L58_t061.camdev_cice5.026g_1_16

---

• b.e23_alpha16b.BLT1850.ne30_t232.033_2_12_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328_gamma0.33_soae.001_1996_2006
• b.e23_alpha16b.BLT1850.ne30_t232.033_2_12_vs_Obs

---

• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328-wsub_scale0.1.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328-wsub_scale0.1.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

---

• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328-wsub_scale0.5.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328-wsub_scale0.5.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328-wsub_scale0.5.002_1995_2006_vs_Obs
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328-wsub_scale0.5.002_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006

---

• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328_gamma0.33.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328_gamma0.33.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

---

• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328_gamma0.33_soae.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328_gamma0.33_soae.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328_gamma0.33.001_1995_2006

---

• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs
• f.cam6_3_119.FLTHIST_ne30.r328.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250_gamma_coefb0.3.001_1995_2006

---

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.wsub.001_1995_1999_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_1999

---

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250_gamma0.3.001_1995_2004_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2004

---

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250_gamma_coefb0.3.001_1995_2004_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2004

---

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250_dcs250.001_1995_2004_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2004

---

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.wsub_min0.002.001_1995_2005_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2005

---

[justin-richling]

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.slowsnow.001_1995_2005_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2005

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.slowsmice.001_1995_2005_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2005

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.slowice.001_1995_2005_vs_f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_2005

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_1999_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_117.FLTHIST_ne30.r250.001_1995_1999_vs_f.cam6_3_107.FLTHIST_v0a.ne30.clm5_1.001_1995_1999

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi2.0-wsubi3.5-newhb.001_1995_1998_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi2.0.001_1995_1998

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5_zm_water.001_1995_2005_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2005

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi1.5-hb-tt.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi1.5.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi2.0-wsubi5.0.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi2.0.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi1.5.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi2.0.001_1995_2000_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2000

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi2.0.001_1995_2000_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FMTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.7_taubgnd2.5.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FMTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.7.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-wsubi1.0.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi1.0.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-dcs500.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-gamma.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-c8_4.0.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-wsubi1.0.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-dcs500.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5-vtrmi1.0.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006

[justin-richling]

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2005_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FMTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.7.001_1995_2005_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2005_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FMTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.7.001_1995_2005

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-rdg_beta0.5.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-qbo-hdepth.002_1995_1998_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3.001_1995_1998

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_109.FLTHIST_v0b.ne30.tuningF_non-ogw.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-zmconv_tau.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3-zmconv_ke.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FMTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.7.001_1995_2000_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT-effgw0.3.001_1995_2000

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30_L32.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006_vs_f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006

• f.cam6_3_112.FLTHIST_v0c.ne30_L32.non-ogw-ubcT.001_1995_2006_vs_Obs

• b.e23_alpha13b.BLT1850.ne30_t232.031_1_7_vs_b.cesm3_cam058_mom_e.B1850WscMOM.ne30_L58_t061.camdev_cice5.026g_1_7